Rinnovabili • EU ETS reform: more free carbon permits for industry Rinnovabili • EU ETS reform: more free carbon permits for industry

EU countries push for more free industrial carbon permits under EU ETS reform

Ireland has proposed changes to the EU carbon market that would slow the phase-out of free emission allowances for industry and ease decarbonisation requirements for smaller installations.

Google Add Rinnovabili to your Google favorites

EU ETS reform: Ireland proposes slower cuts to free emission allowances

The Irish Presidency of the Council of the European Union has put forward a compromise proposal to extend the availability of free carbon emission allowances for industry and exempt smaller installations from certain new decarbonisation obligations. The changes form part of negotiations over the planned EU ETS reform, which has become a contentious issue among Member States.

The proposal aims to break the deadlock over one of the EU’s most important climate policy instruments. Member States and the European Parliament must each agree on their negotiating positions before interinstitutional talks can begin to finalise the legislation. The Irish Presidency hopes to secure an agreement ahead of the Environment Ministers’ meeting on 11 December.

EU ETS reform: Member States face negotiations over carbon efficiency benchmarks

The compromise text is due to be discussed on Wednesday, 18 November. Brussels is seeking to revise the EU Emissions Trading System (ETS) to align it with the target of reducing net greenhouse gas emissions by 90% by 2040 compared with 1990 levels.

The ETS was originally designed around the EU’s 2030 climate target. Without further changes, the supply of free emission allowances would fall to almost zero by 2039.

Each year, approximately 57% of ETS allowances are auctioned, while the remainder are allocated free of charge to industrial operators to help limit their CO₂-related costs. This mechanism supports the competitiveness of European industries against international rivals that do not face equivalent environmental compliance costs.

Several Member States have called for more free allowances, also citing rising energy costs. The 27 EU countries must now reach an agreement on how to revise the carbon efficiency benchmarks used to determine future allocations of free emission permits.

Industrial benchmarks could change how free allowances are allocated

According to the Irish compromise document reviewed by Reuters, one of the most significant changes concerns the industrial benchmarks used to calculate free allocations for the steel, chemicals, cement and fertiliser sectors.

Under the proposal, benchmarks would be based on the most efficient installations accounting for 10% of a sector’s production volume. This would replace the current methodology, which uses the 10% of installations with the highest efficiency levels.

Industry groups argue that the existing approach allows a relatively small number of highly efficient facilities to exert disproportionate influence over the benchmarks.

The proposed text would also introduce annual updates to benchmark reductions, replacing the current five-year adjustment cycle. Together, these changes would result in a more gradual reduction in free emission allowances.

Smaller industrial installations could be exempt from decarbonisation plans

The Irish proposal would also exempt smaller installations, defined as those that received fewer than 5,000 free allowances during the previous allocation period, from the European Commission’s proposed requirement to submit decarbonisation investment plans.

For larger installations, the compromise introduces greater flexibility. Companies would be able to access the final 20% of their free allocation once construction of an eligible decarbonisation project has begun, rather than having to wait until the project is completed, as envisaged under the Commission’s original EU ETS reform proposal.

The Irish text would also provide additional opportunities for companies to pool investments across industrial clusters and value chains.

It further specifies that certain investments in heat pumps connected to district heating networks could count towards the required decarbonisation investment commitments.

EU ETS reform could bring forward the use of international carbon credits

Ireland has also proposed allowing the earlier use of international carbon credits under the EU ETS.

According to Bloomberg, the proposal would introduce a pilot phase between 2031 and 2035, during which companies covered by the ETS could potentially use high-integrity imported carbon credits to meet part of their compliance obligations.

Under the European Commission’s proposal presented in July, EU companies would only have been allowed to use high-quality international credits from 2036 onwards.

International carbon credits would originate from projects designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions outside the EU.

The Irish proposal establishes six bands for projected purchases of these credits, each corresponding to a different annual reduction in the system’s emissions cap.

The proposed annual reductions range from 1.7%, as envisaged by the Commission, to 2.7%. According to the document, lower projected purchases of international carbon credits would result in faster reductions in the overall emissions cap.

The compromise therefore seeks to reconcile demands for greater industrial flexibility with the emissions reduction trajectory required under the EU’s climate objectives.

Rinnovabili •

About Author / Erminia Voccia

Professional journalist with a passion for storytelling and a keen eye on global dynamics. She holds a Master’s degree in International Relations and two postgraduate diplomas in journalism and broadcast journalism. She began her career in television, producing reports for national news programs, and later worked as a freelancer for several national newspapers, online outlets, and specialized magazines. Her writing has focused on the environment, international affairs, and geopolitics, with a particular interest in Asia. She has also managed event planning and communication for a publishing house and contributed to the editing of academic essays. At Rinnovabili, she mainly covers climate and climate policy.